Hi Paul, I can’t ‘see’ gravity, but I can see, and feel, it’s effects so it must be true. That's a logical conclusion. It's a concept. What is true is that it's harder walking up hill. That things resist being lifted, etc. You can only impute a cause. Remember we are not interested in explaining the...

All good answer Madhura, is there anywhere that you feel needs looking at before i give you the 'final' questions?

much love

vince

Hi Sylwia, another guide has come up with this to help clarify 'the see-er'. Witness/Observer/Senses Exercises Exercises Seeing Exercise - Part I The usual belief that 'I am this body' is usually tied in with the belief that the body as a separate item is responsible or 'DOING' the senses - 'I see',...

Hi Pattea, I'm sorry for my absense - some family stuff. no worries. It's taken me 2 days to get to your post too. no self, but "something" sensed as ME. this is a big one. When you say "something sensed as me" I want you to dissect that into something sensed, and additional to that a logical conclu...

Hi Steve, In my experience, it doesn't seem to belong to anyONE but by definition it's that which defines belonging as a concept. Good. Now go straight into that. That “thing which defines belonging”— Where is it? What is it made of? Can you touch it, hold it, locate it? Or is it just another though...

Hi Madhura, no need for apologies. i liked most of your answers. Here are some more questions to find what needs more investigation. Don’t rush.
Don’t answer from the head.
Let each question strike.
 Feel it. Let the body show you where something grips, contracts, hides, resists. — 1. Right now—can ...

Hi Paul

any thoughts?

Yes. Don't just read it and be amused. Do it!
Go through each line and take them quite literally.
Read a line. Stop. Consider it a literal instruction. Contemplate it before moving to the next line.

vince

Hello Pattea, I want to stay here one-on-one with you. Is that possible? Absolutely. Thank you for your time with me. Thanks not needed (but thank you) It's a joy.. No, there's nothing tangible to manage. Beautiful. i'm going to assume that this is how it feels and it's not just mind talking. Or is ...

Meetings are: An update... There is now a meet up every Saturday at 9pm(AEST) & one every Monday 7am (AEST) & one every Wednesday 4pm (AEST) & one every Friday 7am (AEST) (this one not published) Please note that it's always the same time on the same link Arriving late and leaving early is fine. Yo...

Hi Sylwia, a guide has asked for A definition of each one without a "self," and an example, for 5) a) Describe decision, intention, free will, choice and control. What makes things happen? How does it work? Give examples from your own recent experiences to how these things happen and how they work. ...

Sensations in the body are strong sometimes. Tingling, vibrating. Not know what this is. Not attached to emotion or thought. An aliveness(not as spiritual description) as if I can feel mechanisms of movement in veins, arteries, muscles. Strangeness. Perfect. This is exactly what arises when the fil...

I have been guiding Liu by email. He was uncomfortable with the forum. here are his answers and below is a follow up on his answer to Q1. 1) Is there a separate entity 'self', 'me' 'I', at all, anywhere, in any way, shape or form? Was there ever? The answer is no. I partly got the answer by rational...

I can't see a center and a controller but there is something watching How do you know that there is some thing watching? Is it a logical conclusion or do you experience a watcher or do you experience watching? If I say now I will move my pinky and do it it seems action is following thought. If acti...

hi Sylwia,

hope to see you on Zoom.

Yes, looking forward to that. We can go deeper and explore that which is more subtle there.
It's very pleasurable working with you.

Much love

vince

Hi TD, I'm not sure if there is an expected frequency of communication or not.. i am happy for you to respond when the impulse takes you. Just be aware of the practical value of momentum. I wonder if I should deliberately fire up my discipline muscle Definitely not. That is down a completely maladap...